Why Size-Based Analysis Matters
Relationship between population size and method selection — constraints of know-how, capacity, and market environment
Unit costs and amounts in financial examples without a cited source are illustrative assumptions, not statistically established market rates. Use estimates and comparable records appropriate to the target facility, location and business when preparing a project plan. Distinguish these assumptions from cited statistics and case expenditure.
Priority Review Procedure adoption rate (pop. 200,000+, as of end of March 2025; 92 of 112)
82.1%
Same (pop. 100,000–200,000; 93 of 145)
64.1%
Same (pop. 50,000–100,000; 41 of 237)
17.3%
Population floor for municipalities asked to formulate a Priority Review Procedure (after the 4 June 2025 guideline revision)
50,000
PPP/PFI methods are diverse, and no single method suits all municipalities. Three key variables influence method selection:
- Market environment (private operator interest): Larger cities attract more operator interest and support competitive procurement. Small municipalities face a realistic risk of "zero applicants"
- Internal capacity (know-how and staffing): Smaller municipalities report significantly higher rates of "insufficient understanding, know-how, and staffing" as barriers
- Facility scale and project cost: PFI Act projects typically require project costs of ¥1 billion or more, making them overbuilt for small facilities
The Cabinet Office published a guide for small and medium municipalities in October 2024, formally recognizing the importance of size-appropriate method selection.
Small Municipalities Under 50,000
Staged approach using Designated Manager, proposal-based selection, and small concessions
Realistic Method Options
Scroll horizontally to read the whole table.
Recommended Staged Approach
For small municipalities, a staged approach rather than jumping directly to the PFI Act is effective:
Step 1: Adopt/improve the Designated Manager System for existing facilities (build internal know-how) Step 2: Utilize idle facilities through proposal-based selection (gain collaboration experience) Step 3: Progress to small concessions or Park-PFI (gain operating rights and revenue experience)
Success Requirements for Small Municipalities
- Leverage wide-area collaboration: Conduct joint sounding surveys with neighboring municipalities to secure private operator access
- Utilize external support: Leverage regional block platform training and the Cabinet Office's PPP/PFI expert dispatch program
- Mayoral leadership: In small municipalities, the mayor's decision-making directly determines project momentum
Medium Municipalities: 50,000–200,000
The optimal zone for Park-PFI and small concessions with staged expansion
Optimal Zone Methods
Medium municipalities occupy the zone where PPP/PFI method options are widest.
Scroll horizontally to read the whole table.
Park-PFI and Small Concession Strategies
Three success factors for Park-PFI in medium municipalities:
- Location: Sites with steady daily visitor flow (adjacent residential areas, station proximity)
- Sounding survey execution: Pre-verify private operator interest and project condition feasibility
- Coexistence with surrounding commerce: Ensure park revenue facilities do not undermine nearby existing businesses
Small concessions were defined as targeting idle public property with project scales under approximately ¥1 billion in November 2023. They are well-suited for former municipal offices, health centers, and kindergartens held by medium municipalities.
Priority Review Procedure Response
The 2025 revision of the guidelines, adopted on 4 June 2025, widened the range of municipalities asked to formulate a Priority Review Procedure to those with populations of 50,000 or more. For municipalities in the 50,000–100,000 range, formulating the procedure itself becomes a new task. Referring to the Cabinet Office formulation guide and embedding it into internal project evaluation processes is essential.
Implementation Model: Toyoake City, Aichi (Population ~70,000)
Toyoake City in Aichi Prefecture stands out as a representative case of a population-70,000-class municipality that has successfully operationalized a Priority Review Procedure. Toyoake's implementation contains several practical innovations that medium municipalities can emulate.
Scroll horizontally to read the whole table.
The Toyoake case demonstrates that even medium municipalities can sustain a continuous project pipeline through "institutional design that retains external experts in permanent positions" and "operational practice that positions designated manager renewals as the entry point for priority review"—even with a small promotion team.
Large Municipalities: 200,000+
Full-spectrum method selection including PFI Act and concessions with promotion structures
Full-Spectrum Method Selection
Core cities and designated cities with populations of 200,000+ can access all PPP/PFI methods.
Scroll horizontally to read the whole table.
Internal Promotion Structure Design
In large municipalities, while method options expand, internal promotion structures determine success. Fukuoka City, after experiencing the Thalasso Fukuoka PFI project failure, established a city-wide "Optimal Project Method Review Committee" in 2011 and developed clear public-private partnership criteria.
Method Selection Flowchart
Decision criteria by facility type, project scale, and regional characteristics
The following flowchart provides decision criteria for method selection based on facility characteristics:
Step 1: Assess project cost scale
- ¥1 billion+ → PFI Act consideration (proceed to Step 2)
- Under ¥1 billion → Small Concession / Park-PFI / Designated Manager (proceed to Step 3)
Step 2: Consider facility operation model
- User fee revenue expected → Consider concession or independent revenue PFI
- Administrative service delivery is primary → Consider service purchase PFI
Step 3: Identify facility type and location
- Urban park → Park-PFI
- Idle property (former offices, abandoned schools) → Small Concession / Proposal-based
- Existing facility management → Designated Manager System
Step 4: Verify market interest via sounding
- Multiple operators express interest → Proceed to selection method design
- No interest → Revise project conditions or continue direct management
Related Articles
PPP/PFI Introduction for Municipal Officials
From PPP vs. PFI to the full landscape of seven methods
PPP/PFI: Seven Methods Compared
Cross-cutting comparison of Designated Manager, Park-PFI, Small Concession, PFI Act, and more
What Is a Small Concession?
Overview of the small-scale operating rights framework and why it is gaining momentum
What to do next
When considering PPP/PFI, review the facility conditions and the municipality's rules.
Scroll horizontally to read the whole table.
Check project cost and the municipality's rules to establish whether priority review applies, then compare methods suited to the facility's use and expected income.
References
Research Report on PPP/PFI Adoption in Municipalities with Populations under 200,000 — Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications (2021)
PPP/PFI Promotion Guide for Small and Medium Municipalities — Cabinet Office Private Finance Initiative Promotion Office (2024)
PPP/PFI Promotion Action Plan (Revised 2024 Edition) — Cabinet Office Private Finance Initiative Promotion Office (2024)
The Great Tide from Small Concessions — Sumitomo Mitsui Trust Research Institute (2024)